Eat Well, Live Happy: All-Clad Stainless Steel D3 Tri-Ply Cookware Review

A few years ago I posted a review on the Calphalon Tri-Ply Stainless Steel Cookware that my husband I received as wedding gifts. Due to my extreme boredom during this Coronavirus stay-at-home order, I am going to give you an update!

I really loved this cookware, but last summer I noticed that water was getting trapped in the glass lids and that mildew was forming in there - yuck! I never would have noticed this if one of the lids on my most-used pot hadn't developed a mildew smell. It took me a while to figure out what was causing the smell, but once I saw the water moving around and mildew in the lid, I was pretty disgusted. I initially thought the issue was only with this one pan, so I brought it to Bed Bath & Beyond at the end of June since I could not get ahold of Calphalon, after attempting to several times by calling and filling out online forms. After much hassle from Bed Bath & Beyond's customer service due to their new return policy, they agreed to replace the pan for me. When I received the new pan I noticed water was still getting stuck in the lid, and then I looked at all of my other lids and noticed water moving around in every single one of them!

I was extremely disappointed because our big cookware set was gifted to us by my aunt and her daughter and daughter-in-laws for my bridal shower and the other individual pieces were wedding gifts from a few other family members and friends. I thought it would last us forever and was disappointed that after less than 4 years of marriage, there was an issue with it.

Water trapped in old lid

I contacted Calphalon again towards the end of July since they claimed to have a lifetime warranty. At first, they apologized and sent me a new set of lids for every piece of cookware I had, which was quite a few lids. In the clean new lids, it was even more apparent that water was getting trapped in them. No amount of air drying or towel drying could remove this water. It remained in the lid even after leaving them to dry overnight.

Water trapped in new lid

I contacted Calphalon again in the beginning of August, not knowing what they would do to remedy this, and to my surprise they offered to give me a full refund for my entire set of cookware. They sent me pre-paid FedEx labels and I had to mail everything back which was a small inconvenience just because of the amount of pots and pans we have and the weight of the cookware, but I was happy that I would no longer have to cook with mildew in my lids. I eventually ended up receiving the full refund, but it took a few months and SEVERAL phone calls and emails to Calphalon before they gave me all of the money that was owed to me. It was such a huge hassle to have to keep calling them, spending a lot of time on hold waiting to actually talk to someone (during my precious "free time" when my twins were napping), explaining the same thing over and over again to each new person I talked to even though everything was in their notes from the last time I had called in, and not getting anywhere with the refund for a long time. They initially only paid me less than half of what I was owed even though they told me the refund would be based on MSRP prices. No one ever contacted me to let me know why the amount was less. I had to contact them several more times to find out what was going on. I went on their website and added up the cost for everything I had shipped back to them, and determined the MSRP total, yet their own employees could not figure this out! Luckily since I knew what was owed to me and I was persistent, I eventually received the correct amount of refund. I shipped all of my cookware to Calphalon on August 8th, received the first refund on November 8th and the second on December 21st. This entire process since I first noticed the water stuck in the lids and contacted Calphalon until I received the full refund took 6 whole months! Can you imagine if I had been without any cookware for all of that time? Needless to say, after this experience with their customer service and lack of follow-up on their part, I will never purchase another Calphalon product again for myself or anyone else.

Since I sent back all of my cookware I set out on a search for a new set and ended up deciding to go with a highly rated well-known classic, All-Clad Stainless Steel D3 Tri-Ply. This was the other set that I was originally trying to decide between before I registered for the Calphalon set. Ironically, I chose the Calphalon set over the All-Clad because I wanted glass lids - what a mistake! The reality is that once the lids steam up you can't see well in them anyway. All-Clad is more expensive, but I was able to purchase everything on sale which helped me justify the upgrade. Although these two cookware sets are pretty similar, I can definitely tell a difference after cooking in both of them. The All-Clad is a nicer set all around. It cooks better and cleans up easier. If you are looking for a new set of cookware to purchase or register for, I definitely recommend going with All-Clad D3 Tri-Ply. Since their lids are stainless steel, you won't have to worry about water getting trapped in them!

Below are the All-Clad pieces that I purchased. I spent some additional money beyond the Calphalon refund for these. I wanted to get everything I thought I would need in the coming years. I looked for the best deals and purchased these online from different places, including Macy's and Bloomingdale's (they go on sale for 30% off on both of these websites plus they came with additional free pieces!), Williams-Sonoma (one of the pans was an exclusive there and I had a 25% off coupon), and the Navy Exchange website (lower prices and tax-free for military).

The big set that I purchased is the All-Clad D3 Stainless Steel 10-Piece Cookware Set. There are a few different sets that you can choose from but this one had pieces that I knew I would use. I decided to purchase the other pieces I wanted separately, rather than buying a set with more pieces that I didn't need. This is a great starter set that includes:

8" fry pan

10" fry pan

2-qt. covered saucepan

3-qt. covered saucepan

3-qt. covered sauté pan

8-qt. covered stockpot

10-piece Cookware Set

Some websites sell a very similar set with a different 3-qt. pan - they call it a "casserole pan" or "soup pot" instead of a sauce pan which just means it has two small loop handles instead of the long stick handle. I personally preferred the sauce pan in this particular size. With the purchase of the 10-piece set, I also received a "free gift" of an All-Clad Stainless Steel 15" Oval Baker and Pot Holder Set. I have yet to use this, but I'm sure it will come in handy one day. Due to a mix up with my order, I actually received two of these oval bakers and was told by Macy's to keep them both, so I ended up giving one to my sister Paula, who is my only sibling with the same All-Clad set that I have.

Oval Baker & Pot Holder Set

In addition this this great set, I purchased some individual pots and pans to go with it, based on what I knew I would use.

I also purchased the 1.5-qt. Covered Saucepan for a great price from the Navy Exchange website so I would have an additional small saucepan. It's the perfect size to heat up a serving of food, a bowl of soup, etc. I'm glad I found this for a great price because I use this one quite often.

1.5 quart Saucepan

Two pans that I had in my old set that I did not now have were a 12" fry pan and a Wok. I didn't use either of these super often but there were times I needed the larger size pans. In place of these two pans, I purchased a 4-qt. Covered Weeknight Pan. This is a great, large pan that can be used for lots of different dishes. I love this pan, and I don't miss the 12" fry pan or Wok at all!

4 quart Weeknight Pan

Update July 2024: I purchased a 4-qt. Casserole Pan to replace the 4-qt. Weeknight pan. I found that I rarely used the Weeknight pan due to the shape of it and I prefer the flat sides of the Casserole Pan, and the double handles versus having a long handle. This also makes the Casserole Pan much easier to store in my cabinet! It is only sold at Sur La Table. Luckily I had $25 in "SLT Perks" that I used on my order which helped bring the price down a bit.

4 quart Casserole Pan

I also wanted more stock pots. The 8-qt. size that comes with the set is great, but I wanted some smaller and larger options for making pasta, sauce, soup, etc. I used my 25% off coupon to order the 4-qt. Soup Pot with Ladle, which can only be found at Williams-Sonoma. There is another 4-qt. option that is a saucepan with a long handle available at other stores, but I liked this one more, and the ladle that it comes with is a nice bonus! This is the stockpot that I use the most right now for my family of 4 (including two toddlers who don't eat much yet), as it fits a pound of pasta perfectly. I also use it to make small soup recipes.

4 quart Soup Pot with Ladle

Since there is a pretty big difference between a 4-qt. stockpot and an 8-qt. stockpot, I wanted a size in between them as well. I ordered the 6-qt. Covered Stockpot, which I originally didn't even like and was considering returning because it is more wide and shallow than I am used to for a stockpot. It turns out that I have used this stockpot more than any of the other larger sizes so far. It's perfect for cooking spaghetti, soup, pasta dishes and so many other things. I'm so glad I kept it and I highly recommend it!

6 quart Stockpot

Coming from a very large family, I knew I would need some even bigger stock pots, so I waited for the best sale I could find and after a while I also purchased the 12-qt. Covered Stockpot and the 16-qt. Stockpot with Lid. While these may not get used often, they are great to have for when I want to make a big pot of soup or sauce. These are rather expensive stockpots so I waited until they were 30% off, and I also received a "free gift" of the All-Clad Petite 14" x 11" Stainless Steel Roaster with Rack.

I had already purchased the All-Clad Large 16" x 13" Stainless Steel Roaster with Rack on clearance from the Navy Exchange website for a very low price. I previously had a similar Calphalon roaster that I returned with all of the cookware and I will say that there is a very clear difference in quality between the two, with All-Clad being far superior. Even just from picking them up I could feel the difference in quality.

12 quart Stockpot

16 quart Stockpot

Small Roaster

Large Roaster

That concludes the All-Clad pots and pans that I purchased. It was helpful that I knew what types and sizes of pots and pans I cook with most often to be able to narrow down the set and additional pieces that would be best for me. If I had registered for these pans when I was engaged, I would not have known what I would be using most. Between all of these and my collection of Le Creuset, we are set for life! However, after seeing how nice the quality of All-Clad was, I got a little out of hand and purchased a few All-Clad accessories when I found them on sale for 25% or 30% off or had a coupon or gift card.

My old set of cookware had a steamer and a double boiler, which I now no longer had since I returned them with the cookware. I initially purchased the All-Clad 3-qt. Stainless Steel Steamer with Lid, but did not like how the bottom of it was oddly shaped, so I returned it and purchased the All-Clad Stainless Steel 3-qt. Steamer Insert, which I like much more and can be used with lids I already have. All-Clad also makes a larger 8-qt. steamer but since we don't use a steamer much, I opted for the smaller size.

3 quart Steamer Insert

I also purchased the All-Clad Stainless Steel 3-Piece Mixing Bowl Set. These can be used as double boilers, but obviously have so many other uses as well. I love the handles on these and find them very helpful. I read some reviews that said they scratch easily, so I do not use my hand mixer in them - problem solved! Update July 2024: I prefer using my OXO mixing bowls and never really used these bowls, so I listed them for sale.

Mixing Bowl Set

I have a few plastic colanders already, but never registered for or purchased stainless steel ones. I found the All-Clad Stainless Steel Colanders, Set of 3 on sale and used gift cards to purchase them which brought the cost down considerably. I would not have paid anywhere near full price for these just because they are so expensive, but they are very sturdy and nice quality. This set includes a 1.5-qt, 3-qt. and 5-qt. colander, but they can all be purchased separately as well. These nest into each other for storage. After all these years, it's so nice to have a stainless steel colander set!

Colanders

The last thing that I purchased were some kitchen tools. I have a lot of OXO nylon kitchen tools which I really like and use every day, especially because they will not damage my Le Creuset pieces, but I wanted some good quality stainless steel tools that I could use in all of this new cookware. I used a coupon and gift card to purchase the All-Clad Stainless Steel Kitchen Tool Set w/Caddy from the Navy Exchange website. I also purchased the All-Clad Stainless Steel Skimmer, Pasta Ladle, Pierced Spatula/Large Slotted Turner, and Set of 2 Turkey Forks from Bloomingdale's when they were all 30% off. I purchased these extra tools along with the two largest stock pots, which helped me get the "free gift" of the small roaster. These tools are all very nice quality.

6 Piece Tool Set with Caddy

This is our whole All-Clad collection. The All-Clad pots and pans are all made in the USA, but all of the accessories are made in China. There seems to be some confusion about what is made where so I wanted to clear it up! I can tell by the excellent quality that these will last us forever, and since I purchased such a variety of pots, pans and accessories, I don't anticipate needing to add any more to our kitchen.

I also wanted to mention that cleaning this cookware is very easy. A lot of people complain that food gets stuck on stainless steel cookware and that is just not true if you cook in it correctly. It is not like using non-stick cookware if that is what you're used to. You should never cook above medium heat on stainless steel cookware (or cast iron) unless you are boiling water. You should also let the pan heat up and add oil or butter to it before adding food. To clean, simply wait for the pan to cool down and then soak it in hot water for a while, then just use a non-abrasive sponge (I use the yellow Dobie pads) and it should be easy to clean. Never put a hot pan in cold water - that will cause thermal shock and could ruin your pan. I never use steel wool on my pans. For any stubborn stains, using Bar Keeper's Friend works wonders and makes your pots and pans look as close to like-new as they will ever get!

This was a long, detailed post but I hope you found this review helpful! Since this stay-at-home order will not be lifted any time soon, I will post a review of my Le Creuset cookware soon.